13 drives: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
What's the best setup for 13 drives? I don't need high performance (this will be mostly for archiving media), but very much do not want to lose my data. The drives are 18TB, and [[ZFS]] will be used exclusively.
What's the best setup for 13 drives? I don't need high performance (this will be mostly for archiving media), but very much do not want to lose my data. The drives are 18TB, and [[ZFS]] will be used exclusively.
<b>MinFail</b>: This many failures will kill the array in the worst case.<br>
<b>MaxTol</b>: This many failures can be tolerated in the best case.


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! Name !! Setup !! Availability !! Tolerance !! Max Rebuild !! Perf
! Name !! Setup !! Availability !! MaxTol !! MinFail !! Max Rebuild !! Perf
|-
|-
| raid3z
| raid3z
Line 8: Line 11:
| 76.9% (10)
| 76.9% (10)
| 3
| 3
| 4
| 100% + fail
| 100% + fail
|
|
Line 15: Line 19:
| 69.2% (9)
| 69.2% (9)
| 3
| 3
| 4
| 92.3%
| 92.3%
|  
|  
Line 22: Line 27:
| 84.6% (11)
| 84.6% (11)
| 2
| 2
| 3
| 84.6% + fail
| 84.6% + fail
|
|
Line 29: Line 35:
| 76.9% (10)
| 76.9% (10)
| 2
| 2
| 3
| 76.9%
| 76.9%
|
|
Line 36: Line 43:
| 61.5% (8)
| 61.5% (8)
| 2 + 2
| 2 + 2
| 3
| 30.8%
| 30.8%
|
|
Line 43: Line 51:
| 76.9% (10)
| 76.9% (10)
| 1 + 1
| 1 + 1
| 2
| 46.2%
| 46.2%
|
|
Line 50: Line 59:
| 61.5% (8)
| 61.5% (8)
| 1 + 1 + 1 + 1
| 1 + 1 + 1 + 1
| 2
| 25%
| 25%
|
|
Line 57: Line 67:
| 30.8% (4)
| 30.8% (4)
| 6 + 2
| 6 + 2
| 6
| 46.2%
| 46.2%
|
|
Line 64: Line 75:
| 38.5% (5)
| 38.5% (5)
| 6 + 1
| 6 + 1
| 4
| 46.2%
| 46.2%
|
|
|}
|}


==14 disks==
14 disks might be more attractive; I work that out [[Schwarzgerat_III|over here]].
 
14 disks might be more attractive. I only list solutions without a hot spare.
 
{| class="wikitable"
! Name !! Setup !! Availability !! Tolerance !! Max Rebuild !! Perf
|-
| raid3z
| 11 data, 3 parity
| 78.6% (11)
| 3
| 100% + fail
|
|-
| raid2z
| 12 data, 2 parity
| 85.7% (12)
| 2
| 85.7% + fail
|
|-
| striped raid3z
| 2x(4 data, 3 parity)
| 57.1% (8)
| 3 + 3
| 50% + fail
|
|-
| striped raid2z
| 2x(5 data, 2 parity)
| 71.4% (10)
| 2 + 2
| 50% + fail
|
|-
| striped raidz
| 2x(6 data, 1 parity)
| 85.7% (12)
| 1 + 1
| 50% + fail
|
|-
| mirrored raid3z
| 2x(4 data, 3 parity)
| 28.6% (4)
| 7 + 3
| 50% + fail
|
|-
| mirrored raid2z
| 2x(5 data, 2 parity)
| 35.7% (5)
| 7 + 2
| 50% + fail
|
|-
| mirrored raidz
| 2x(6 data, 1 parity)
| 42.9% (6)
| 7 + 1
| 50%
|
|}